In the Flash
Subscribe
Cover photo

An Olympic-Size Problem: How to Portray the Bodies of Female Athletes

On photographing cross-country skiing legend Jessie Diggins — in the nude — while avoiding the slippery slope of objectification.

Dina Litovsky

Feb 18
3
64

.............................

In 2009, the now-defunct ESPN magazine released their first Body Issue. Its biggest competitor at the time was Sports Illustrated, and Sports Illustrated’s biggest clickbait was the annual Swimsuit issue. How do you compete with supermodels in bikinis? By photographing the world's top athletes in the nude. The first Body Issue came out featuring Serena Williams, naked, covering herself tastefully and shimmering in body oil. Checkmate.

For the next decade, ESPN released the annual issue with athletes from every imaginable sport, from soccer to NFL to skateboarding. The photos were exquisitely produced, intended to feature the bodies proudly and without any Photoshopping, leaving all the marks, bruises and “imperfections.” All the private bits had to be covered in creative ways, through the use of body positioning or lighting. It was an early exercise in bypassing Instagram censorship.

.............................

For ESPN's 10th (and penultimate) annual issue, I photographed American cross-country skier Jessie Diggins. Jessie won the United States’ first-ever gold medal in her sport at the Winter Olympics in 2018 and just now she snagged bronze in the 2022 Beijing Olympics, making her the most decorated American cross-country skier of all time. Still, Jessie Diggins is not a household name. Sports have their own unique popularity scale. Though cross-country skiing is one of the most grueling Olympic sports, it also has the unfortunate distinction of being one of the least watched because of its long distances and lack of immediate thrills. Jessie was the first and only cross-country skier featured in the whole decade of the Body Issue.

.............................

When the New York Times covered Jessie Diggins’s memorable win last week, they drew a lot of ire for this description: "In a sport that has so many women with massive shoulders and thighs, Diggins looks like a sprite in her racing suit, and it’s not clear exactly where she gets her power."

The backlash concentrated on the stark description of the bodies of women athletes. Critics took offense at the phrase “massive shoulders,” a not-too-flattering adjective for the female physique, preferring instead "upper body strength." They also pointed out that commenting on Jessie's body was insensitive because of her past struggles with her own body image. It was fascinating to read the ensuing discussion on the distinction between objectifying and describing. The debate had a familiar ring to it. When I photographed Jessie, this was the main conceptual challenge I was grappling with. How do I photograph a nude photo of a fit, blond young woman without edging towards objectification?

.............................

A concern less monumental though no less difficult was the fact that the shoot had to be done in Jessie's natural environment, on skis in a snowy Vermont wonderland. The only difference was that she was naked. Cross-country is a sport of endurance, strength and patience, and I got to see all of that expressed in how Jessie masterfully braved 30-degree weather. We worked in 15-minute intervals, in between which she warmed up inside a nearby heated hut. There was a lot of hot coffee and chocolate. To make Jessie more comfortable, all the 6 people on set — editors, assistants, make-up and hair crew —were women.

.............................

The shoot was planned in two parts, “documentary” and posed. For the first part, the images were intended to look dynamic, the camera gliding in sync with Jessie, at the same time showcasing and obscuring her body. Concentrating on movement revealed the muscles in action, tense and working, like a hidden mechanism. For several shots, I positioned the camera behind the trees to show Jessie skiing alone in the forest. Training for cross-country skiing is often a solitary exercise and I wanted to give a glimpse of that mindset. In these images Jessie seems lost in thought, oblivious to the camera. By contrast, in the more posed shots, Jessie is confronting the camera squarely with her gaze, securing a power balance between the subject and the viewer.

.............................

Athletes' bodies are subject to constant scrutiny. It's no wonder — their physical attributes are inseparable from what often seem to be their superhuman abilities. The ESPN Body Issue was powerful because it peeled back the curtain for us, mere mortals, to see what happens to a body subjected to various types of rigorous training. It gave a visual to what "upper-body strength" can look like in many different forms. I didn't love the NYTimes description of athletes because it somewhat flippantly reduced the sport to a single physical type. But I didn't understand why it could read insensitive towards Jessie. An athlete's body and proportions don't have to be coddled by vague adjectives. When I photographed Jessie Diggins, I saw in front of me a fearless young woman proud to show off the body that she has worked on so relentlessly. She trusted both me and the magazine to successfully tread the sometimes blurry line between celebrating and objectifying. I suspect that, in the end, we succeeded.

.............................

.............................

Jessie Diggins in the ESPN 10th Annual Body Issue.

Find me on Instagram @dina_litovsky

Subscribe for free to In the Flash
By subscribing, you agree to share your email address with Dina Litovsky to receive their original content, including promotions. Unsubscribe at any time. Meta will also use your information subject to the Bulletin Terms and Policies
3
64

More from In the Flash
See all

The Sticky Issue of Consent in Street Photography

How a lovely family image became an internet controversy
Nov 12, 2021
5
59

Becoming a Photographer Because of My Mom, and Despite Her

A belated Mother's Day post for Ida.
May 9
3
13

Getting the Party Started at the People’s Ball in Brooklyn

The reality and illusion of photographing parties.
May 4
1
2
Comments
Log in with Facebook to comment

64 Comments

  • Rick Hernz
    Masters of Deception: all they had to do to undress women is to tell them its "liberating" and "empowering".
    Bravo.
    • 12w
  • Cheri Anderson
    How do we convince women that they are only popular enough if they pose naked? are the men doing these shoots also? Is it a women run magazine and women photographer? so young girls striving to have credibility as athletes say what to this?
    • 12w
    4 Replies
  • Kory Cowen
    I think it’s you guys did a beautiful job with the picture. Jessie is an amazing athlete and finally we see them with all the touch up’s to make them look perfect. She is already in great shape but we don’t see bruises on anyone else’s photos and it’s…
    See more
    • 12w
  • Jack Butler
    Sex sells. Always will. Attractive will attract. Feelings be hurt. Happens every minute of every day
    3
    • 12w
    2 Replies
  • William Irvine
    Well, what did Jessie Diggins have to say about your description?
    • 12w
  • Peter Kaufman
    Just curious. Some comments are intended to describe some of the reasons that some of you find these photos distasteful or in some way damaging to women yet the same comments express with glee the thought of seeing similar photos of men. so I’m curiou…
    See more
    • 12w
    1 Reply
  • Thomas Ford Conyers
    What a load of fucking shit. First of all, outside of complete sociopaths, ”objectification” is bullshit. Finding someone physically attractive doesn’t somehow detract from respecting them as a human being. The two aren’t mutually exclusive, nor is it …
    See more
    • 12w
    1 Reply
  • Brian Spies
    As a figurative photographer that often shoots people in no or barely any clothing I definitely think the key is to create an environment where the subject feels both empowered and at ease. Thank you for sharing your insight behind these shots and yes,…
    See more
    • 12w
  • Todd Higgins
    How about don’t take naked photos of them?
    • 12w
  • Stuart Burhans
    After being an athlete all of my life from high school to a league and billion baseball in football I got a scholarship for that and also it is amazing to see a beautiful woman social skill and amazingly beautiful you have to realize this is not about …
    See more
    • 12w
View 35 more comments
Share quoteSelect how you’d like to share below
Share on Facebook
Share to Twitter
Send in Whatsapp
Share on Linkedin
Privacy  ·  Terms  ·  Cookies  ·  © Meta 2022
Discover fresh voices. Tune into new conversations. Browse all publications